The Failure of Nonviolence: From the Arab Spring to Occupy

Courtesy

The Failure of Nonviolence
28 February, 2014 – open salon – Dr Stuart Jeanne Bramhall

The Failure of Nonviolence: From the Arab Spring to Occupy
By Peter Gelderloos (2013 Left Bank Books)

Book Review

You occasionally read a totally mind bending book that opens up a whole new world for you. The Failure of Nonviolence by Peter Gelderloos is one of them, owing to its unique evidence-based perspective on both “nonviolent” and “violent” resistance. It differs from Gelderloos’s 2007 How Nonviolence Protects the State in its heavy emphasis on indigenous, minority, and working class resistance. A major feature of the new book is an extensive catalog of “combative” rebellions that the corporate elite has whitewashed out of history.

Owing to wide disagreement as to its meaning, Gelderloos discards the term “violent” in describing actions that involve rioting, sabotage, property damage or self-defense against armed police or military. In comparing and contrasting a list of recent protest actions, he makes a convincing case that combative tactics are far more effective in achieving concrete gains that improve ordinary peoples’ lives. He also explodes the myth that “violent” resistance discourages oppressed people from participating in protest activity. He gives numerous examples showing that working people are far more likely to be drawn into combative actions – mainly because of their effectiveness. The only people alienated by combative tactics are educated liberals, many of whom are “career” activists working for foundation-funded nonprofits.

Gelderloos also highlights countries (e.g., Greece and Spain) which have significantly slowed the advance of neoliberal capitalism via combative resistance. In his view, this explains the negative fiscal position of the Greek and Spanish capitalist class in addressing the global debt crisis. Strong worker resistance to punitive labor reforms and austerity cuts has significantly slowed the transfer of wealth to their corporate elite, as well as the roll-out of fascist security measures.

The Gene Sharp Brand of Nonviolence

Gelderloos begins by defining the term “nonviolent” as the formulaic approach laid out by nonviolent guru Gene Sharp in his 1994 From Dictatorship to Democracy and used extensively in the “color revolutions” in Eastern Europe and elsewhere. This approach focuses exclusively on political, usually electoral, reform. Gelderloos distinguishes between political revolution, which merely overturns the current political infrastructure and replaces it with a new one – and social revolution, which overturns hierarchical political infrastructure and replaces it with a system in which people self-organize and govern themselves.

The nonviolent approach Sharp and his followers prescribe relies heavily on a corporate media strategy to promote their protest activity to large numbers of people. This obviously requires some elite support, as the corporate media consistently ignores genuine anti-corporate protests. As an example, all the nonviolent color revolutions in Eastern Europe enjoyed major support from the State Department, billionaire George Soros and CIA-funded foundations such as the National Endowment for Democracy and the National Republican Institute.

Is Nonviolence Effective?

Gelderloos sets out four criteria to assess the effectiveness of a protest action:

– It must seize space for activists to self-organize essential aspects of their lives.
– It must spread new ideas that inspire others to resist state power and control.
– It must operate independently of elite support.
– It must make concrete improvements to the lives of ordinary people.

As examples of strictly nonviolent protest movements, Gelderloos offers the “color” revolutions (see 1 below), the millions-strong global anti-Iraq war protest on February 15, 2003 and 2011 Occupy protests, which were almost exclusively nonviolent (Occupy Oakland being a notable exception).

In all the color revolutions Gelderloos describes, the goal has been strictly limited to replacing dictatorship with democracy and free elections. None attempted to increase economic democracy nor to reduce oppressive work and living conditions. In fact, most of the color revolutions forced their populations to give up important protections to integrate more thoroughly into the cutthroat capitalist economy.

So-called “democracies” such as the US are just as capable as dictatorships of engaging in extrajudicial assassination, torture, and suspension of habeas corpus and other legal protections. However US corporations generally find “democracies” more investment-friendly. Owing to greater transparency, they are less likely to nationalize private industries or arbitrarily change the rules for doing business.

Besides failing to meet any of his criteria, the 2003 anti-Iraq war movement failed to stop the US invasion of Iraq and the 2011 Occupy protests failed to achieve a single lasting gain.

Successful “Combative” Protests

He contrasts these strictly nonviolent protests with nearly 20 popular uprisings (see 2 below) and two (successful) US prison riots that have incorporated “combative” tactics along with other organizing strategies. Most have been totally censored from the corporate media and history books or whitewashed as so-called “nonviolent” actions (e.g., the corporate media misportrayed both the 1989 Tiananmen Square rebellion and the 2011 Egyptian revolution as nonviolent protests).

The US, more than any other country, uses prison to suppress working class dissent. Most prison struggles employ a diversity of tactics combining work stoppages and legal appeals with property damage, riots and attacks on guards. Nonviolent protest tends to be particularly ineffective in the prison setting. A nonviolent hunger strike usually reflects a situation in which prisoners have so little personal control that the only way to resist is to refuse to eat.

Gelderloos also analyzes a number of historical combative uprisings, pointing out their relative strengths and weaknesses. He devotes particular attention to the Spanish Civil War (a failed working class revolution), the anti-Nazi partisan movements during World War II, combative Indigenous peoples resistance to European colonizers and autonomous liberated zones created in Ukraine, Kronstadt, and Siberia following the Bolshevik Revolution and in the Skinmin Province of Manchuria in pre-World War II China.

Who Are the Pacifists?

He devotes an entire chapter to the major funders and luminaries of the nonviolent movement. Predictably most of the funding comes from George Soros, the Pentagon, the State Department and CIA-funded foundations such as USAID, NED, and NIR. Among other examples, Gelderloos describes the Pentagon running a multi-million dollar campaign to plant stories in Iraqi newspapers to promote “nonviolent” resistance to US occupation. …more

34 thoughts on “The Failure of Nonviolence: From the Arab Spring to Occupy”

  4. Промокод – это комбинация символов, которую вводят в специально отведенную строку на сайте. После активации кода, пользователь получит вознаграждение от любимого БК. Обычно к промокоду прилагается подробное описание всех предлагаемых бонусов. Но иногда букмекеры позволяют игрокам выяснить назначение кода самостоятельно, ведь многие любят сюрпризы. В случае с промокодом, сюрприз наверняка окажется приятным, ведь его главная цель – создать игроку комфортные условия, заслужить лояльность. Существуют промокоды для новых игроков, которые действительны только при регистрации, и для постоянных – окно для ввода таких кодов находится под формой пополнения игрового баланса. Melbet промокод на депозит Введите: RS777 и тогда при депозите вы получите бонус 10400 рублей автоматически. Букмекерская контора Мелбет в 2024 году создала комфортные условия для заядлых беттеров и новых пользователей. Промокоды – вещь распространенная, потому найти их легко. Часто букмекеры размещают коды в свободном доступе, для всеобщего пользования. А промокоды для более значимых наград поступают игрокам индивидуально, например в качестве подарка ко дню рождения, извинения за возможные неудобства или просто в благодарность за сотрудничество.

  9. vibration analysis
    The Importance of Vibrations Mitigation Apparatus in Industrial Equipment
    Within manufacturing contexts, equipment along with turning machinery act as the support of production. Yet, one of the most common challenges which could impede its operation and durability exists as vibration. Vibrations may cause a series of issues, ranging from lowered accuracy as well as performance leading to increased wear and tear, in the end leading to pricey delays as well as restoration. This is when resonance control equipment proves to be critical.

    The Reason Oscillation Control is Crucial

    Vibration in machinery may result in various detrimental consequences:

    Lowered Production Productivity: Exaggerated resonance could bring about discrepancies and distortion, lowering the efficiency with the machinery. This may bring about delayed output times along with increased electricity usage.

    Greater Wear and Tear: Constant resonance increases the damage to machinery parts, causing increased repairs and the risk for unanticipated unexpected issues. This doesn’t merely heightens operational costs and limits the durability of the machinery.

    Security Concerns: Excessive oscillation may bring significant dangers to both the machinery and the operators. In, extreme situations, such vibrations can result in disastrous equipment breakdown, endangering operators as well as causing considerable devastation across the facility.

    Exactness and Production Quality Problems: In businesses that depend on exact measurements, such as manufacturing or space industry, vibration may cause flaws in manufacturing, producing defects as well as greater waste.

    Cost-effective Options towards Vibration Regulation

    Investing in oscillation control tools is not just a necessity but a wise choice for any industry that relies on equipment. Our advanced vibration management systems work to engineered to eliminate oscillation from various mechanical systems as well as rotating equipment, ensuring uninterrupted along with effective performance.

    What distinguishes these tools above the rest is its economic value. We understand the necessity of cost-effectiveness within today’s competitive market, and for that reason we have high-quality vibration management solutions at prices that won’t break the bank.

    By choosing our equipment, you’re not only securing your mechanical systems and boosting its efficiency but also putting investment towards the long-term performance of your business.

    Final Thoughts

    Vibration control remains an essential aspect of maintaining the effectiveness, safety, and lifespan of your industrial equipment. Through our cost-effective oscillation control systems, it is possible to ensure your processes run smoothly, all manufactured items maintain top quality, as well as all personnel remain safe. Don’t let vibrations compromise your company—invest in the correct apparatus today.

  10. Internet gambling sites deliver an exhilarating array of games, numerous of them these days integrate crypto as a payment option. Of the best sites, BC Game Casino, Fortune Panda, Axe, and Bitkingz are becoming popular, whereas Bit Starz distinguishes itself through several awards. Cloud Bet Casino is recognized as being a regulated crypto casino, guaranteeing security for players and integrity, and Fair Spin Casino together with MB Casino deliver a broad selection of crypto-compatible games.

    When it comes to dice games, digital currency casinos including Bitcoin Dice provide an exciting gambling experience, permitting gamblers to wager in Bitcoin and other virtual currencies like Ether, LTC, DOGE, Binance Token, and USDT.

    For online gambling enthusiasts, choosing the right casino provider matters. Thunderkick Casino, Play’n Go Casino, Red Tiger, Quickspin Casino, Pragmatic, Playtech, Nolimit City, NetEnt, ELK Studio Games, and Microgaming are some of the leading game providers renowned for their innovative slot machines, engaging graphics, and intuitive interfaces.

    Gambling streams has grown into a popular method for gamblers to get involved with virtual casinos. Top streamers for example ClassyBeef, Roshtein Casino, David Labowsky, Deuce Ace, and X-Posed broadcast their casino sessions, often showcasing massive jackpots and giving insight into the best strategies in gambling.

    In addition, sites like BC Casino, Bitkingz, and Rocketpot Casino also include Plinko-style games, a widely played game with basic rules yet great potential for high payouts.

    Learning about responsible gaming, cashback deals, and playing anonymously in crypto casinos are essential for bettors wanting to optimize their experience. Picking the best crypto wallet, looking for no-registration-required casinos, and acquiring tactics for games such as Aviator helps players keep up-to-date while playing the thrill of the game.

  16. 1xBet промокод на бонус при регистрации. Букмекерская контора предоставляет игрокам множество возможностей для снижения рисков и увеличения банка. Бонусная программа компании предусматривает интересы как новичков, так и опытных бетторов. Рассмотрим основные виды поощрений в функционале БК: 1хБет промокод на регистрацию – один из самых популярных подарков, созданный для новых игроков на сайте; Ставки на спорт – увеличение депозита до 32500 рублей. Воспользуйся актуальным промокодом 1xbet на сегодня, получи бесплатную возможность увеличить свой первый депозит до 32500 рублей в БК 1xBet. Воспользовавшись промокод на 1хбет при регистрации, максимальная сумма бонуса возможного бонуса будет увеличена до 32500 рублей. Но при этом сумма бонуса будет равна сумме вашего первого депозита – более подробно в этом материале https://www.jkfitness.com/wp-content/pags/1xbet___promo_code_for_registration.html

  21. Если реализуется демонтаж с заменой нижних венцов, тогда брус или разгружается от напряжения и происходит замена, поскольку для замены поднятие не выше 10 см сантиметров, которое не является существенным в том числе для внутреннего оформления.

    нижние брёвна или брус из лиственных пород намного долговечно и надёжно и успешно доказал свою надежность своей прочностью и устойчивостью к разрушению. При этом, ее также обязательно нужно обеспечивать защиту с помощью антибактериального препарата, наряду с и все перекладины.

    Наша компания работает не исключительно ремонтом конструкций, дополнительно улучшением полов. Потребители часто заказывают утепленные полы и перекрытия с термической изоляцией мы Комплектуем клиента материалами и предоставляем индивидуальные тарифы.

  22. Паркетная доска – это тип напольного покрытия, состоящий из деревянных планок, которые укладываются в виде палубной доски. Она отличается высокой долговечностью и прочностью, а также придает интерьеру теплую и уютную атмосферу. Паркетная доска может быть изготовлена из различных пород дерева и иметь различные оттенки и текстуры, что позволяет подобрать подходящий вариант под любой стиль помещения. https://kvarcvinil3.ru/

  30. Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем:ремонт крупногабаритной техники в екатеринбурге
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  33. В магазине напольных покрытий представлены различные виды напольных покрытий и выберите тот, который соответствует вашим потребностям. Например, ламинат подходит для помещений с высокой проходимостью, кварцвиниловая плитка полностью водостойкая, подходит для любых в том числе и влажный помещений, а ковровое покрытие создаст уютную атмосферу в спальне. https://ламинат1.рф/

  34. Este rotativo de equilibrado con canasto de embrague representa un procedimiento critico con el proposito de verificar el funcionamiento excelente del motor y la transferencia de un camion. El falta de equilibrio en esta parte llega a causar vibraciones, estrepito, desgaste excesivo de los componentes e incluso averias. En el pasado, el estabilizacion se efectuaba una vez sacar el volador del motor, no obstante las desarrollos contemporaneas posibilitan efectuar este metodo de manera directa en el automotor, lo cual minimiza tiempo y costos.

    Cual es el Desajuste?

    El falta de equilibrio simboliza una condicion en la en la que la peso de un componente rotacional (en este escenario, el girador de balanceo con compartimento de embrague) se localiza de forma desigual en funcion de su eje de rotacion de revolucion. Esto provoca fuerzas centrifugas que causan vibraciones.

    Principales del Falta de equilibrio del Volante de Nivelacion con Canasto de Embrague:

    Desviaciones de construccion y ensamblaje: Aunque minimas variaciones en la estructura de los elementos tienden a originar desbalance.
    Envejecimiento y danos: El funcionamiento prolongado, el exceso de calor y los desperfectos mecanicos llegan a afectar la volumen y resultar en desequilibrio.
    Ensamblaje o servicio deficiente: Una ensamblaje inapropiada de la canasto de embrague o arreglos incorrectos igualmente llegan a originar desajuste.

Comments are closed.